Federico Fellini's Nights of Cabiria depicts the story of a
streetwalker named Cabiria living in Rome. The film illustrates the idea of the
cliché golden-hearted prostitute, but Cabiria exceeds this idea in her own way.
She has an innocent soul, but on the outside she is callous and ill tempered. Despite
this, the events of the movie prevent her from having the typical happy ending
we see in these movies.
A typical
golden-hearted prostitute in a film is a good person with a rough past who
often becomes a love interest for another main character. Cabiria fits this
role in that she is sweet and believes in love. This is shown during the magic
show scene when Cabiria is hypnotized and thinks she is talking to a man named
Oscar. She talks about her youth when she was eighteen and how she wishes he
had met her then before she became a prostitute. She obviously believes in love
and wishes she could find true love, but back in reality when she is not
hypnotized she would never share these feelings. Cabiria has developed a tough
exterior to avoid those feeling and getting hurt.
Even though Cabiria
fits the idea of the golden-hearted prostitute, she meets men who are not like
the typical love interests. At the beginning of the film we see Cabiria and
Giorgio. It’s easy to assume they are a normal couple in love. When he steals
her purse, pushes her in the river, and runs off we realize that this is not a
typical love story. Cabiria realizes what happened after she is revived, and
from then on she is very cautious with the men she encounters.
She meets the famous
actor named Alberto Lazzari who picks her up and takes her out to a nightclub,
but ends up treating her poorly. He hides her in the bathroom when his
girlfriend comes back and then has to sneak her out in the morning. Cabiria is
cautious with him, and doesn’t know what to expect that night. She doesn’t seem
to be too upset about the events of the night because of this.
Cabiria also meets
Oscar. At first, he seems like the typical love interest that she’s been
waiting for. She is also cautious with him and keeps wondering what he wants
from her. He is loving and affectionate and convinces her that he loves her. He
doesn’t want to know about her past or how she earns her living. He fools
everyone, however, and turns out just like Giorgio. Once she realizes it has
happened again, she decides to change her own life, instead of waiting for a miracle
or for the Madonna to do it for her.
In the end, the
golden-hearted prostitute exceeds the cliché and walks away without a man. She
is still the tough, callous woman from before, but now she is able to decide
her own fate. It is not the typical happy ending love story that is expected,
but it shows that things doesn’t always end up perfect, and we have the power
to decide our own lives.
In the Fellini film, I would agree that Cabiria is not the typical lovable prostitute. While I am aware of the stereotype of the prostitute with a heart of gold, I cannot really think of that many examples in film. At the top of my head, I can only think of Pretty Woman and The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas. Of course, I’m just guessing because I have never seen either one. Regardless, Cabiria is a character whose longing for love and a better life is so intense, that the audience feels for her. The loudness and rude attitude may make her a bit caustic at times, but give her a realistic edge that I would imagine many movies miss. In Cabiria, we see her flaws as well as her charms and both play off of each other.
ReplyDeleteI do not believe that her run in with Giorgio makes her any more cautious. After all, she falls into the same trap with Oscar and is almost murdered the exact same way. Before this she goes to Alberto’s house alone. But in the end, I think he treats her pretty well. While she is locked in the bathroom all night, he did at least pay her for this. Of course how cautious can a prostitute be?
I am not sure that I know for certain how she has changed at the end of the movie. For it ends with her smile, but what exactly the smile reflects on the inside, or where it may lead her is nebulous. While Cabiria is not the typical prostitute with a heart of gold, this is a good thing. She is far more realistic and in the end, far more loveable.
-Jacob Karnes: Group 7-